Dr. Shane Lipskind has been performing tubal ligation reversals since training in advanced laparoscopic and microsurgical techniques as a reproductive endocrinology and infertility (REI) fellow. He has performed hundreds of tubal ligation reversals for his patients with extremely high rates of success.
Dr. Lipskind uses an operating microscope or the daVinci surgical robot to perform all of his end-to-end tubal microanastomoses. He prefers to use the operative microscope in most cases because it can magnify the operative field many more times than surgical loops or the robotic laparoscope, and thus provides better visualization so that extremely small sutures can be used to reunite the fallopian tubes. Because he uses permanent sutures so small they’re barely visible to the naked eye, there is virtually no inflammatory response from the surrounding tissue, and the risk of tubal re-occlusion or scar tissue-induced ectopic pregnancy are drastically reduced.
Due to his meticulous technique, Dr. Lipskinds rates of tubal patency after microanastomosis exceed 90%, which means that your tubes are highly likely to remain open. Pregnancy and live birth rates after successful microanastomosis are then dependent upon the age of the female partner and the couple’s natural fertility. This is why some basic testing, including ovarian reserve testing and semen analysis, are recommended prior to tubal reversal. Fertile women under the age of 35 can expect greater than an 80-85% chance of having a child within two years of the surgery. Although ACFS always counsels extensively regarding the risk of ectopic pregnancy after any tubal surgery, tubal pregnancy affects fewer than 5% of patients who become pregnant after tubal reversal at our center.
Dr. Lipskind is so committed to his patients’ success that if he repairs both of your tubes by end-to-end microanastomosis and neither tube remains open, he will waive his physician fees for In Vitro Fertilization (IVF).*
Patients often worry that their tubal sterilization cannot be reversed if they have had their tubes cut, tied, burned (cauterized), or any combination of the three. Although some tubal sterilizations are easier to reverse than others (Filshie clips, Hulka clips, and Falope rings), it actually does not matter how your sterilization was done. The most important factor is the length of the tubal segments that were left unharmed. A full-length fallopian tube measures 8-12 centimeters long, and most sterilization procedures remove or damage 2-5 cm of the tube. We want our patients to have greater than 4 cm of tubal length remaining so that the newly repaired tubes will function as they should and provide an excellent chance for pregnancy. For these reasons, we always make an effort to obtain operative reports from the tubal ligation surgery when they are available. Sometimes, unfortunately, the operative reports reveal that the fallopian tube was removed or destroyed in its entirety. Learning this ahead of time can save you a disappointing and needless trip to the operating room. In most cases, however, the operative reports will reassure us that the odds of being able to complete your tubal ligation reversal are high.
In addition to obtaining the prior surgical records, we also perform a diagnostic laparoscopy at the start of every reversal surgery to confirm that there is enough healthy tube remaining. Operative reports do not always match what was actually done or the current status of the tubes because inflammation and scarring during the healing process can do additional damage after the tubal ligation itself. To do the laparoscopy, we make a tiny incision in the belly button and insert a long, thin camera into the abdomen to look directly at the fallopian tubes. Approximately 95% of the time, this will confirm that we can do the reversal.
Some clinics recommend a hysterosalpingogram (HSG) to see if there is enough tubal length prior to the surgery. The problem with HSG is that it only hints at how much tubal segment there is up to the point where the tube was “tied.” It cannot expose how much tubal length remains beyond that point. This can mislead us to believe that there is not enough tube remaining if the tubes were tied close to the uterus, or that it will be an easy reversal when the second half of the tube may have been completely removed or destroyed. Therefore, we do not use HSG to determine whether a patient is a candidate for a tubal reversal.
First, your anesthesiologist will make sure that you are asleep and comfortable in the operating room. Then, a catheter will be placed into the uterus to allow for injection of a sterile blue dye to show that the fallopian tubes are open after completion of the repairs. A small incision is then made in the belly button, and the abdomen is inflated with CO2 gas. The laparoscope will be inserted into the abdomen to visualize the fallopian tubes. When it is confirmed that a reversal can be performed, a small bikini incision (mini-laparotomy) of less than 2.5 inches is made right above the pubic bone. Once access to the fallopian tubes is established, new tubal openings are created, and the operating microscope brought into position. The tubes are then reunited using microsurgical technique and approximately 4 sutures for the inner layer of each tube and 10 sutures for the outer layer, or serosa. The blue dye is injected when the anastomoses, or re-joining of the tubes, are complete, confirming that the dye spills freely from the end of the tubes and that the repair sites are water-tight. Upon completion of the anastomoses, the abdominal incision is closed in layers. The skin incision is closed with absorbable suture. Anesthesia is then reversed, and you are taken to the recovery area for observation.
If your tubal ligation was performed too close to where the tubes attach to the uterus or you had an Essure sterilization, then you will not be a candidate for an end-to-end tubal microanastomosis. You may, however, be a candidate for tubal reimplantation, a procedure in which a new opening is made in the uterus and the distal fallopian tube is inserted. The fallopian tubes are held in place by a stent that is removed three months later in the office.
Although tubal reimplantation surgery is an effective technique, it is important to note that tubal patency rates and pregnancy rates are lower than the more common end-to-end anastomosis (approximately 60% tubal patency after reimplantation vs. over 90% for traditional reversal). Due to the fact that tubal patency is much more dependent on your body’s healing rather than surgical technique, the reversal guarantee does not apply to tubal reimplantation or Essure reversal. In addition, patients undergoing tubal reimplantation must allow three months of uterine healing time before attempting pregnancy and will be required to deliver by c-section.
The actual procedure takes 2-3 hours, and you can go home the following morning.
The surgery is performed under general anesthesia so that you are completely asleep and comfortable throughout the procedure. Occasionally, patients will be candidates for spinal anesthesia and may stay awake during most of the surgery.
Complications from tubal reversal surgery are rare. The procedure is less risky than a c-section and carries about the same risk as a tubal ligation. Operative risks shared by all forms of abdominal surgery include bleeding, infection, injuries to nearby organs or structures, and medical complications such as blood clots or poor reactions to medications. Fortunately, not one of our patients has ever required a blood transfusion or had a serious surgical complication.
Risks specific to the tubal reversal include: (1) the small chance that neither tube can be repaired, (2) the chance that the tubes are successfully repaired but that a patient still has difficulty conceiving due to other forms of infertility, (3) the possibility of a tubal or ectopic pregnancy, and (4) the rare possibility that the tubes are repaired but do not remain open.
The initial recovery time is approximately two weeks, but some patients report feeling 80-90% recovered in just one week. Most often, Dr. Lipskind will tell you that you are safe to return to work, drive a car, and start trying to become pregnant after your two week postoperative appointment. There are no physical restrictions after 6 weeks.
The average time to pregnancy after the surgery is about 6-7 months. Pregnancy may take longer if only one tube was able to be repaired since you can ovulate from either side any given month. In such cases, Dr. Lipskind may offer treatment with low dose fertility medications to improve the odds of ovulation on the side that was successfully repaired.
As soon as you are late on your period or have a positive home pregnancy test, you should notify ACFS so that we can send you an order for a blood pregnancy test (serum quantitative hCG). We will follow the rise in hCG to ensure that the levels are increasing normally and schedule you for your first ultrasound between 5-6 weeks’ gestation (usually within two weeks of your first positive pregnancy test). Once we confirm that the pregnancy is in the uterus, you are generally home free, and we perform this ultrasound at no additional charge.
Successful pregnancy depends on the age of the woman. Live birth rates range from 40% at age 40-42 to over 85% for women under the age of 35. Miscarriage risk is not increased as a result of the reversal surgery. If a couple is not successful in conceiving within 6 months after tubal reversal, we will recommend an x-ray, or HSG, to document tubal patency. Once the tubes are confirmed to be open, the couple can continue to attempt pregnancy naturally or expand their evaluations for other sources of infertility and start treatment for non-tubal infertility.
The total cost of tubal ligation reversal at ACFS is $9,985. This includes your pre- and post-operative visits, a comprehensive semen analysis, the tubal reversal procedure, anesthesia, and the HonorHealth facility fee (which includes an overnight stay).
Your initial consultation of $300 can be applied to the cost of the procedure. The required HIV, Hepatitis B, Hepatitis C, AMH, FSH, and estradiol blood tests for tubal ligation reversals can be completed through your primary care provider or a diagnostic laboratory that is contracted with your insurance.
In-Vitro Fertilization (IVF) is the main alternative to tubal ligation reversal. There are advantages and disadvantages for both treatment options. Since ACFS has a great deal of experience and excellent results with both surgery and IVF, we are in a unique position to provide an unbiased assessment of which treatment may be better for any particular couple. In the end, if patients are good candidates for either procedure, we feel strongly that it should be the patient’s choice—not ours—which guides her treatment.
Advantages for IVF include:
Disadvantages for IVF include:
The advantages and disadvantages of tubal ligation reversal are pretty much the inverse of the pros and cons for IVF. Extenuating circumstances aside, we find that cost becomes the deciding factor for most couples who would be good candidates for either treatment. We are very happy that IVF is becoming more cost-competitive with tubal ligation reversal. In most cases, however, the reversal is still less expensive. IVF may be offered for an advertised price of less than $10,000, but this does not include all of the necessary testing, medications, and some of the most important services that IVF patients desire, such as preimplantation genetic testing and frozen embryo transfer. More realistically, IVF costs at least $10,000-15,000 per attempt (and sometimes $20,000 or more) after all of the costs of testing and medications are factored in. Additionally, if IVF is not successful the first time, you will have to pay for another embryo transfer or even a second round of egg retrieval. In contrast, after the one-time cost of the reversal, you can attempt pregnancy for as many months and years as you want.
If you’ve had a tubal ligation and are interested in tubal reversal surgery or IVF, what are you waiting for? We are experts in both of these treatments and have helped countless patients from Arizona and from out-of-state who were told that they would never be able to have children again. Call ACFS to schedule your consult today.
“My wife went in and had a tubal reversal. Three months later she is pregnant!! Thank you Dr. Lipskind for doing an excellent job! Everyone who works there was kind and helpful. Now just hoping for a girl??”
“Dr. Lipskind reversed my tubal ligation back in March of 2015. I am now holding our newest addition, a healthy 10 week old little boy. He helped us through the entire journey and made us feel so comfortable. Even when we miscarried back in 2016 he was a great support. I tell everyone I know that is looking for a fertility doctor to go see him. He gave us what we thought we could never have...another baby. He is amazing.”
*The tubal reversal guarantee does not apply to Essure reversal or tubal reimplantation, to patients who are recent or current smokers, to patients with diabetes or other conditions that negatively affect healing, or tubal re-occlusion due to factors beyond Dr. Lipskind’s control, such as subsequent pelvic surgeries or infections. Costs of IVF above and beyond Dr. Lipskind’s physician fees are still applicable.
If you want to learn more about tubal ligation reversals, call your ACFS fertility team today at (480) 630-0212.